Ontario Energy Strategy: Nine New Unconventional Oil & Gas Pipelines

Posted by Don Richardson and Emily Ferguson

Nov 25, 2014 8:44:00 PM

Have you seen the other nine new pipelines in Ontario?

Unconventional oil and gas in Ontario can be hard to see if you don't know where to look, but it's all around the province.

This is the second in a new series of posts by Don Richardson and Emily Ferguson on how "Unconventional Oil & Gas are Reshaping Ontario’s Energy Landscape"  Sign up for our newsletter to stay in touch!
Sign-up for Our Newsletter!

 

Where are the other NINE new pipeline projects in Ontario?

The premiers of Ontario and Quebec recently teamed up on energy, climate change and strengthening economies.  They've agreed to work together to fight climate change and build a stronger and more competitive low-carbon economy.  These two Canadian climate change leaders also agreed to work together to ensure that the Canadian Energy Strategy being developed by the provinces and territories takes climate change objectives into account and works to strengthen economic development.  We're getting more optimistic about Ontario's energy future, but there's work to be done enhancing Ontario's energy strategy.

Getting a lot of media attention was the Ontario-Quebec agreement on seven joint principles and collaborative work to guide their respective decisions concerning pipeline projects, including TransCanada's proposed Energy East pipeline project. While most of the media attention is on Energy East, we noted that the operative word in Ontario's media release was "projects".  So, what other pipeline projects are out there that might benefit from joint principles and collaborative work between the two provinces?  How do these pipeline projects fit with fighting climate change, Ontario pipeline regulations and building a more competitive low-carbon economy?

 

We've identified nine new pipeline projects, beyond Energy East - and there are likely more to come, so read on, because... 

 

Ontario has become a pipeline hub

Ontario sits in the midst of a rapidly changing unconventional energy boom – a reality that hasn't received much media attention or government policy consideration thus far. Supply and demand chains are changing, massive pipeline networks are being built, and the Ontario's Long Term Energy Plan is having difficulty keeping pace.  Ontario sits in the middle of an unconventional oil and gas supply chain, with much of the energy resources simply flowing on pipelines in and out of Ontario from the U.S. and western Canada.  

 

In just the last two years Ontario became a continental hub for the transportation, storage, processing and energy uptake for North American "unconventional" oil and gas.  The flow of these new fossil fuels is rapidly shifting Ontario's energy landscape. A new Ontario Energy Strategy can help Ontario communities and businesses to effectively manage the impacts of this shift - both positive and negative impacts.  

Fresh ideas for a new Ontario Energy Strategy

 

Fresh Ideas for a New Ontario Energy Strategy

We applaud Ontario climate action and we applaud the focus on keeping energy affordable and strengthening the Ontario economy.  Beyond Energy East, we think it's important for Ontario to consider ways to safely harness all the other energy that's flowing through the province on pipelines - especially low-carbon energy products that might dovetail with renewables.  It's time for fresh ideas for a new Ontario Energy Strategy, a strategy that takes account of the unconventional energy boom, low cost natural gas, the drive for sustainable innovation in Ontario, Ontario climate action, and Ontario's position as a pipeline hub for North America.  Such a strategy might include:

  • community and industry-based combined heat and power (CHP) projects using low cost natural gas,
  • City-wide District Energy Systems, combining low cost natural gas with renewable energy and efficient distribution systems,
  • a variety of environmentally safe downstream uses and applications of all the new unconventional oil and gas flowing through the province,
  • lower energy costs for the people of Ontario - especially to revitalize manufacturing, combining low cost natural gas with renewable energy sources at or near manufacturing locations and innovation clusters,
  • using low cost natural gas to reduce the cost and environmental impact of transportation fleets and public transit,
  • extending natural gas pipelines and liquid natural gas and compressed natural gas facilities to develop rural and remote areas of Ontario, and to help Ontario farmers saddled with high energy costs,
  • stimulating growth in Ontario green gas (also known as "renewable natural gas") production and linkages to existing and expanded natural gas transportation systems and markets, and Ontario's emerging rural/agricultural anerobic digestion industry
  • find the ways and means to use natural gas to help safely develop the vast mineral wealth of northern Ontario, including Ontario’s Ring of Fire and aboriginal interests, and
  • forging new commercial energy relationships - particularly with Aboriginal communities whose traditional territories will face impacts from these developments and whose peoples will be seeking opportunities for Aboriginal economic development.

 

A new Ontario Energy Strategy will help to address the many challenges and opportunities that come with tremendous investment in “unconventional” fossil fuels.  Are there challenges, risks and uncertainties? Yes. For example, the jury is still out on the methane greenhouse gas contributions from shale gas, but understanding the risks and challenges is the first step toward solving them.

 

Where is all the new oil and gas coming from?

Unconventional fossil fuel extraction is transforming North America into a new Saudi Arabia.  Big new oil and gas extraction initiatives include:

There's even consideration of shale gas production in southern Ontario, although the economics and social acceptability are questionable.

Marcellus Shale Gas Formation

 

Map of Utica Shale

Potential shale gas in Ontario

These new unconventional energy resources are being transported to, and across, Ontario through new and proposed pipeline networks, and are being stored at unique locations like the massive North America Dawn natural gas storage facility near Sarnia, Ontario, and processed at refineries such as the refining complexes in Sarnia and the Imperial Oil refinery at Nanticoke.  In just a couple of years, Ontario has gone from zero shale gas imports to having 30% - and growing - natural gas in the form of shale gas being imported from the U.S. More and more Ontario is using unconventional gas for electrical power generation at facilities across the province - currently at about 15% of overall electricity generation and growing.  

Natural gas flowing to the Dawn Hub

Natural Gas Supplies to the Dawn Hub in Southwestern Ontario

 

NINE new unconventional oil and gas pipelines in Ontario

Beyond TransCanada's proposed Energy East pipeline, there are nine new Ontario and cross-border pipelines are being proposed and coming on stream rapidly - here are some we're tracking with our clients:

 

1. Enbridge Line 9: This controversial pipeline was slated to begin operation in the Fall of 2014 but is being delayed while decisions are made on where best to put safety valves at important water crossings across Ontario.

2. Enbridge Line 10: Enbridge and its U.S. partner, United Refining are proposing renew the life of the 50+ year old pipeline (built in 1962) for many more years in order to transport oil sands and Bakken crude from Hamilton through the Niagara Peninsula and across the Niagara River (close to Niagara Falls and the intake pipe for Ontario Power Generation's hydro-electric generating station) to New York and Pennsylvania.

Enbridge oil pipelines in Ontario

3. Kinder Morgan's Utica-to-Ontario Pipeline Access (UTOPIA) project: This is a 240-mile, 12-inch diameter pipeline from Harrison County, Ohio, to Kinder Morgan’s Cochin Pipeline near Riga, Michigan, where the company would then move product eastward to Windsor, Ontario and on to NOVA Chemicals’ Corunna, Ontario, facility near Sarnia with ethane and ethane-propane feedstock from new and existing producers in the growing Utica shale basin - initial 50,000 barrels per day (bpd) of capacity, which is expandable to more than 75,000 bpd. The approximately $500 million pipeline project is expected to be in service by early 2018.

 Kinder Morgan's Utica-to-Ontario Pipeline Access (UTOPIA) project

Kinder Morgan's Uitica-to-Ontario Pipeline Access Project -(UTOPIA)

4. Energy Transfer Partners LP's ET Rover natural gas pipeline from Ohio and Pennsylvania to the Dawn Hub natural gas storage facility.

ET Rover pipeline project

5. Enbridge Gas Distribution's $686.5-million pipeline expansion project in Greater Toronto:  The expansion will let more shale gas flow into Ontario, much of it along the Highway 407 corridor right-of-way.

 

GTA / Parkway projects via http://www.desmog.ca/2014/02/05/ontario-approves-importing-us-fracked-gas

6. TransCanada's Eastern Mainline Project: A proposal for 250 kilometres of new natural gas pipeline facilities that will be integrated into the Canadian Mainline system upon completion and tied to TransCanada's proposed Energy East oil pipeline project that will replace northern-eastern Ontario gas pipelines with oil.

TransCanada Eastern Mainline

7. TransCanada's King's North Connection Project: Proposed to connect new Enbridge Gas Distribution pipeline facilities with TransCanada’s existing natural gas transmission facilities in the Greater Toronto Area - "The project will facilitate greater access to these [Marcellus and Utica shale gas] U.S. sources of supply and will serve existing markets in Ontario and Quebec that are expected to remain relatively stable over time." 

TransCanada King's North Connection Project

8. Union Gas' Dawn-Parkway extension project: A proposed 48-inch diameter natural gas pipeline between Hamilton and Milton that connects with TransCanada and Enbridge pipelines in the GTA.

Union Gas' Dawn-Parkway extension projec

 

Union Gas Dawn Parkway System Expansion

9. NEXUS Gas Transmission (NEXUS) system: A proposed shale gas pipeline network to move supplies of Appalachian shale gas to high-demand markets in the U.S. Midwest, including Ohio, Michigan, Chicago and Ontario's Dawn Hub.

NEXUS shale gas transmission project

 

The Bottom Line

Unconventional oil and gas in Ontario can be hard to see if you don't know where to look, but it's all around the province.  

 

Québec and Ontario have agreed on seven principles that must be applied by proponents with respect to pipeline projects.  If these principles are applied to the nine new projects listed above, and others that are sure to follow, we're optimistic about Ontario's energy future:

  • Compliance with the highest available technical standards for public safety and environmental protection;
  • Have world-leading contingency planning and emergency response programs;
  • Proponents and governments consult local communities and fulfill their duty to consult with Aboriginal communities;
  • Take into account the contribution to greenhouse gas emissions;
  • Provide demonstrable economic benefits and opportunities to the people of Ontario and Québec, in particular in the areas of job creation over both the short and long term;
  • Ensure that economic and environmental risks and responsibilities, including remediation, should be borne exclusively by the pipeline companies in the event of a leak or spill on ground or water, and provide financial assurance demonstrating their capability to respond to leaks and spills;
  • Interests of natural gas consumers must be taken into account. 

 

Applying these principles to the nine new projects identified above, will go a long way to enhancing Ontario energy strategy around climate change, sustainabiilty, economic development, Aboriginal community wellbeing, and making the best choices for energy opportunities in Ontario.  We'll be paying close attention. 

 

About Us:

Businesses and organizations are made up of people. So are communities. Imagine a world where people in industry and government, and people from towns of all sizes, get together to make amazing things happen – things they couldn’t have dreamed up alone. A world where people from corporations get together with people in government or NGOs to explore innovative ways to do business while enhancing the natural and social environment. Join us in Creating Shared Value!

At Shared Value Solutions, We speak your language. And we know that the impossible is possible – with the right people in the circle.

We are an Ontario B Corp and we bring the best engineering, design, environment, architecture and other technical discipline expertise to address your challenges and opportunities:

  • Strategic Environmental Assessment guidance, coordination and support
  • Collaborative land and resource use planning and management- process design and delivery
  • Traditional Ecological Knowledge Studies & Traditional Knowledge Studies
  • Traditional Land Use Studies (TLUS)/ Traditional Land Use and Occupancy Mapping
  • Design and delivery of programs promoting/supporting positive behaviour change- environmental stewardship, community-based social marketing, health/environmental health promotion
  • Contributing human environment considerations to technical assessments and management plans in sectors such as water resources, remediation, land use, mining, oil & gas, linear corridor development, forestry, renewable energy, nuclear waste, contaminated sites, brownfield redevelopment, watershed planning, drought planning, water use planning, waste management and waste diversion
  • Aboriginal and Industry Partnerships working with First Nation, Inuit and Métis communities
  • Value Engineering & Value Analysis: we facilitate project teams to optimize a project by understanding functions, objectives, costs and social, cultural and environmental considerations.

Topics: Unconventional Oil and Gas, Sustainability Innovation in Ontario