Our Blog - Shared Value Solutions

The Building Canada Act: Will Current Environmental Standards be Maintained Under the Act?

Written by Meaghan Luis, Scott Mackay, and Meghan Dalyrymple | Nov 17, 2026, 3:25:38 PM

 

One of the biggest questions about the Building Canada Act (BCA) is what it means for Canada’s existing environmental laws and protections, and correspondingly for Indigenous inherent and Treaty Rights and interests.

 

The federal government has introduced the BCA to speed up approvals for designated major projects. However, the Act also changes how certain federal environmental approvals are reviewed, coordinated, and issued.

 

For Indigenous communities, this raises important questions about environmental oversight, the protection of lands and waters, and how project proponents and governments will identify, assess, and address potential impacts on Indigenous and Treaty Rights and territories.  

 

Read on to learn more!

 

 

 

What environmental laws could the BCA affect?

 

In short, the current answer about whether the BCA will uphold current

federal environmental protection provisions is “it depends.”

 

Schedule 2 of the BCA identifies federal legislation that can be included in the consolidated approval process for designated projects. These include:

    • Impact Assessment Act
    • Fisheries Act
    • Species at Risk Act
    • Selected provisions of the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999
    • Migratory Birds Convention Act, 1994

The BCA creates opportunities for designated projects to receive exemptions from certain requirements under these laws or meet some federal requirements through alternative approval pathways.

To answer the question that we asked in the title of this blog, this does not necessarily mean that these laws or their environmental protections are removed. However, it does change how federal regulatory reviews and approvals are carried out for designated major projects , and therefore the extent to which their requirements will be applied or exempted for a given major project. In short, the current answer about whether the BCA will uphold current federal environmental protection provisions is “it depends.”

 

How will federal environmental reviews work? 

 

Under the existing process, federal departments, such as Environment and Climate Change Canada and Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO), review projects under the legislation they administer. Departments also issue their own approvals and conditions.

 

Under the BCA, this process changes for designated national interest projects listed under Schedule 1 of the Act.

 

The Major Projects Office (MPO) coordinates the federal review during the conditions phase of the BCA process (Step 4, as described in our last blog post, and referred to in the chart below). Federal departments review project information and provide technical advice and recommendations. The MPO then brings this input together, developing a consolidated set of proposed project conditions, including conditions to protect the environment and the related rights and interests of Indigenous Nations.

 

Then, the MPO submits a report to Cabinet (also called Governor in Council) with the proposed conditions. The Minister of One Canadian Economy (who is responsible for the MPO) reviews and issues a consolidated conditions document.

 

This means that federal approvals and conditions are brought together under one federal office and Minister rather than being issued through separate decisions by individual departments.


Here is the MPO's process [1], broken down into 5 steps: 

 

If a project proposal meets the BCA criteria and is sufficiently advanced Canada refers it to the Major Projects Office (MPO).

The MPO conducts Crown Consultation on whether to list the project under the BCA with affected Indigenous Peoples and other levels of government. The MPO then issues recommendations to the federal

Cabinet. [3]

The Cabinet decides whether to list the project under Schedule 1 of the BCA. This includes a 30-day consultation notice in the Canada Gazette. If the project is listed, all assessments and permits are deemed to be complete and granted, subject to Step 4.

Federal review to develop specific technical conditions and mitigation measures. If an impact assessment is required, the proponent submits an Impact Statement. Indigenous consultation is focused on conditions and mitigation measures.

The Minister of One Canadian Economy issues a single set of binding conditions for the project.

 

 

How are environmental standards upheld in the conditions document?

The conditions document brings together the federal authorizations, requirements, and conditions that apply to a designated project, including environmental protections. It will include, for example, requirements to protect wildlife and avoid environmental contamination: in other words it will address potential project impacts, including impacts to Indigenous Rights.

 

Transparency is an important part of this process. The BCA requires the government to make the recommendations of federal departments publicly available. This includes providing explanations when recommendations are not accepted. For more details on these reporting requirements, see section 8.1(1) of the Building Canada Act.

 

Ensuring that information is public provides an opportunity to see how project conditions protect the environment and Indigenous Rights and in understanding whether additional mitigation or accommodation measures are required.

 

What are the implications for Indigenous Peoples?

Canadian federal and provincial environmental laws and regulatory reviews have to date provided increasingly important opportunities for Indigenous communities to identify potential impacts on Indigenous lands, waters, wildlife, resources, culture, and rights and pursue mitigation or accommodation measures to address them.

 

While the BCA is intended to reduce duplication and speed up project approvals, changes to the federal review process raise important questions:

    • Will environmental protections be as rigorous under the new approval process?
    • Will the technical recommendations of federal departments aimed at protecting the environment be reflected in the final conditions document?
    • How will Indigenous communities’ knowledge, concerns, and priorities inform project conditions?
    • Who will be responsible for monitoring and enforcing conditions?

 

 

Regardless, input during the two key steps of the BCA process that involve mandatory Indigenous consultation—assessment by the MPO, and the development of conditions (step 2 and 4)—that involve mandatory Indigenous consultation will be crucial. We have identified two specific measures you can take to improve your ability to be ready for and have influence within both consultation processes:

 

1. In the “development of conditions” phase (steps 4 and 5), we highly recommend that Indigenous Nations engage either experienced staff, or an experienced environmental consultant who understands the links between environmental regulatory processes and the duty to consult process. (should you be interested, SVS can definitely help you with this).

 

2. Canada has also recently committed to funding for major project consultations under the BCA. If you are an affected Indigenous community in relation to a project of national interest, the MPO should be engaging you directly about this funding. If you are aware of and potentially impacted by such a project and have not been contacted by the MPO, you can contact them at Email: info@mpo-bgp.gc.ca

 

 

[1] This process diagram is based on Government of Canada information- https://www.canada.ca/en/one-canadian-economy/services/building-canada-act-projects-national-interest.html

 

Our complete Information Blog Series: 

 

Missed a post? Find all of our Major Projects Readiness blog posts here:

 

Concerned about your Nation’s readiness to deal with streamlined project approvals?

 

Shared Value Solutions can help

If you need support, we are here to help! Contact us at info@sharedvaluesolutions.com / 226-706-8888 for more information.

 


SVS Regulatory Advisors:

 

 

 

 

Scott Mackay MSc, RPP

 

Partner and Senior Consultant

 

Learn more about Scott here.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Meaghan Luis, MSc Pl RPP

Senior Environmental Impact and Negotiations Specialist

Learn more about Meaghan here.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Meghan Dalrymple, MA

 

Senior Environmental Impact Specialist

 

Learn more about Meghan here.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Download our Free eBook:

 

Looking for more information on how to manage requests coming into your Lands and Consultation Department?  Check out our Lands and Consultation Guidebook below: